This page details the cost of the Ratelimit algorithms in terms of the number of Redis commands. Note that these are calculated for Regional Ratelimits. For Multi Region Ratelimit, costs will be higher. Additionally, if a Global Upstash Redis is used as the database, number of commands should be calculated as (1+readRegionCount) * writeCommandCount + readCommandCount and plus 1 if analytics is enabled. The Rate Limit SDK minimizes Redis calls to reduce latency overhead and cost. Number of commands executed by the Rate Limit algorithm depends on the chosen algorithm, as well as the state of the algorithm and the caching.

Algorithm State

By state of the algorithm, we refer to the entry in our Redis store regarding some identifier ip1. You can imagine that there is a state for every identifier. We name these states in the following manner for the purpose of attributing costs to each one:

State	Success	Explanation
First	true	First time the Ratelimit was called with identifier `ip1`
Intermediate	true	Second or some other time the Ratelimit was called with identifier `ip1`
Rate-Limited	false	Requests with identifier `ip1` which are rate limited.

For instance, first time we call the algorithm with ip1, PEXPIRE is called so that the key expires after some time. In the following calls, we still use the same script but don’t call PEXPIRE. In the rate-limited state, we may avoid using Redis altogether if we can make use of the cache.

Cache Result

We distinguish the two cases when the identifier ip1 is found in cache, resulting in a “hit” and the case when the identifier ip1 is not found in the cache, resulting in a “miss”. The cache only exists in the runtime environment and is independent of the Redis database. The state of the cache is especially relevant for serverless contexts, where the cache will usually be empty because of a cold start.

Result	Explanation
Hit	Identifier `ip1` is found in the runtime cache
Miss	Identifier `ip1` is not found in cache or the value in the cache doesn’t block (rate-limit) the request

An identifier is saved in the cache only when a request is rate limited after a call to the Redis database. The request to Redis returns a timestamp for the time when such a request won’t be rate limited anymore. We save this timestamp in the cache and this allows us to reject any request before this timestamp without having to consult the Redis database. See the section on caching for more details.

Costs

`limit()`

Fixed Window

Cache Result	Algorithm State	Command Count	Commands
Hit/Miss	First	3	EVAL, INCR, PEXPIRE
Hit/Miss	Intermediate	2	EVAL, INCR
Miss	Rate-Limited	2	EVAL, INCR
Hit	Rate-Limited	0	utilized cache

Sliding Window

Cache Result	Algorithm State	Command Count	Commands
Hit/Miss	First	5	EVAL, GET, GET, INCR, PEXPIRE
Hit/Miss	Intermediate	4	EVAL, GET, GET, INCR
Miss	Rate-Limited	3	EVAL, GET, GET
Hit	Rate-Limited	0	utilized cache

Token Bucket

Cache Result	Algorithm State	Command Count	Commands
Hit/Miss	First/Intermediate	4	EVAL, HMGET, HSET, PEXPIRE
Miss	Rate-Limited	2	EVAL, HMGET
Hit	Rate-Limited	0	utilized cache

`getRemaining()`

This method doesn’t use the cache or it doesn’t have a state it depends on. Therefore, every call results in the same number of commands in Redis.

Algorithm	Command Count	Commands
Fixed Window	2	EVAL, GET
Sliding Window	3	EVAL, GET, GET
Token Bucket	2	EVAL, HMGET

`resetUsedTokens()`

This method starts with a SCAN command and deletes every key that matches with DEL commands:

Algorithm	Command Count	Commands
Fixed Window	3	EVAL, SCAN, DEL
Sliding Window	4	EVAL, SCAN, DEL, DEL
Token Bucket	3	EVAL, SCAN, DEL

`blockUntilReady()`

Works the same as limit().

Deny List

Enabling deny lists introduces a cost of 2 additional command per limit call. Values passed in identifier, ip, userAgent and country are checked with a single SMISMEMBER command. The other command is TTL which is for checking the status of the current ip deny list to figure out whether it is expired, valid or disabled. If Auto IP deny list is enabled, the Ratelimit SDK will update the ip deny list everyday, in the first limit invocation after 2 AM UTC. This will consume 9 commands per day. If a value is found in the deny list at redis, the client saves this value in the cache and denies any further requests with that value for a minute without calling Redis (except for analytics).

Analytics

If analytics is enabled, all calls of limit will result in 1 more command since ZINCRBY will be called to update the analytics.

Dynamic Limits

When dynamic limits are enabled, each limit and getRemaining call will execute one additional command. Both setDynamicLimit and getDynamicLimit execute 1 command each.

​Algorithm State

​Cache Result

​Costs

​limit()

​Fixed Window

​Sliding Window

​Token Bucket

​getRemaining()

​resetUsedTokens()

​blockUntilReady()

​Deny List

​Analytics

​Dynamic Limits